Google’s Guide to Confirming Indexing Issues Due to JavaScript

Google’s Martin Splitt recently shared valuable insights on diagnosing and resolving website indexing issues potentially caused by JavaScript. Presented in a Search Norwich video, Splitt’s advice is particularly useful for SEOs and developers, even those without extensive JavaScript expertise. Contrary to popular belief, JavaScript itself is rarely the root cause of such issues; instead, misimplementation or other factors are often at fault. This guide summarizes key takeaways to help debug and address these challenges effectively.

JavaScript: Rarely the Culprit of SEO Issues

Splitt emphasized that JavaScript is seldom the actual cause of indexing problems. Instead, confirmation bias—where evidence is interpreted to fit a preconceived notion—often leads to inaccurate diagnoses. For instance, many SEOs suspect JavaScript to be the issue, only to discover that a different problem is at play. Splitt noted that in hundreds of cases brought to his attention annually, only one was genuinely linked to a JavaScript bug.

Common Misconceptions

• Misuse of JavaScript: Issues often arise from how JavaScript is implemented rather than flaws in JavaScript itself. Incorrect configuration or improper coding practices are frequent culprits.
• Misinterpreted Errors: Errors flagged in the JavaScript console aren’t always directly related to JavaScript itself. They could stem from blocked resources or server-side issues.
• Blaming Google: Small or niche websites sometimes claim that Google bugs are causing issues. However, these claims rarely hold up, as such bugs would likely affect a much broader range of websites.

Confirmation Bias in Debugging

Splitt described how confirmation bias often drives SEOs to incorrectly blame JavaScript. SEOs may look for evidence to support their preconceived assumptions, ignoring other possibilities. This flawed approach wastes time and resources that could be better spent addressing the real issues.

Tools to Diagnose JavaScript-Related Indexing Issues

Splitt recommends leveraging specific tools to debug and understand how Google interacts with a webpage. These tools can help identify whether JavaScript is genuinely causing problems or if the issue lies elsewhere.

1. Google Search Console’s URL Inspection Tool

The URL Inspection Tool is one of the most powerful resources for identifying indexing issues. It provides insights into how Google crawls and renders a webpage, highlighting:

• The rendered version of the page.
• Indexing status and errors.
• Missing resources or blocked content.

Using this tool, SEOs can determine whether JavaScript is playing a role in rendering issues or if other factors, such as Robots.txt restrictions, are involved.

2. Google Rich Results Test

This tool evaluates structured data and shows how Google interprets the content for enhanced search features, such as rich snippets. If JavaScript affects structured data, the Rich Results Test will highlight inconsistencies or errors, making it easier to pinpoint the source of the problem.

3. Chrome DevTools

Chrome’s DevTools is an indispensable resource for JavaScript debugging. Key features include:

• JavaScript Console Messages: Displays errors and warnings related to JavaScript execution.
• Network Activity: Shows which resources were successfully loaded and which failed.
• Rendering Insights: Highlights any issues in how the page renders, including blocked APIs or incomplete resources.

By combining these tools, SEOs can build a comprehensive understanding of how Google interacts with their webpages, enabling more accurate diagnoses and targeted fixes.

Debugging Rendering Issues

Understanding Google’s Rendering Process

Rendering involves Googlebot downloading webpage resources—such as fonts, CSS, and JavaScript—to create a fully functional version of the page. This process replicates what a human user would experience in a browser. Debugging rendering issues is crucial for identifying whether:

• The page renders correctly.
• Certain elements fail to render.
• The page cannot be indexed at all.

Practical Steps for Debugging

1. Submit the URL to Diagnostic Tools: Use Google Search Console or the Rich Results Test to review the rendered version of your page.
2. Inspect JavaScript Console Messages: Check for errors that might indicate issues with resource loading or execution.
3. Evaluate External Dependencies: Ensure APIs or other resources aren’t blocked by Robots.txt or firewall restrictions.
4. Test Alternate Scenarios: Temporarily disable specific JavaScript functions to isolate potential issues and identify workarounds.

Why SEOs Often Misattribute Issues to JavaScript

Splitt attributes JavaScript’s reputation as a frequent culprit to a lack of debugging knowledge. Many SEOs lack the technical expertise to accurately diagnose problems, leading them to blame JavaScript as a default assumption. By learning a few key debugging techniques, SEOs can:

• Save time by addressing real issues more quickly.
• Reduce reliance on external support for basic problems.
• Gain confidence in identifying and solving indexing challenges.

Examples of Misattributed Issues

• Blocked APIs: Errors may arise from APIs restricted by Robots.txt rather than from JavaScript execution.
• Server-Side Problems: Inconsistent server responses can lead to rendering issues that have nothing to do with JavaScript.
• Improper Resource Loading: Missing fonts or CSS files can impact rendering but are often incorrectly blamed on JavaScript.

Takeaways and Best Practices

Adopt a Systematic Approach

Use diagnostic tools to confirm whether JavaScript is genuinely causing the issue. Avoid jumping to conclusions based on superficial observations or limited evidence.

Avoid Confirmation Bias

Remain open to alternative explanations for indexing or rendering problems. Consider server-side issues, resource restrictions, and improper configurations as potential culprits.

Educate Your Team

Share debugging knowledge within your organization to empower team members to identify and resolve issues independently. This reduces dependency on external experts and accelerates problem-solving.

Optimize JavaScript Usage

While JavaScript is rarely the sole cause of SEO problems, optimizing its implementation can improve overall site performance. Best practices include:

• Minimizing unnecessary JavaScript.
• Ensuring resources load asynchronously where possible.
• Testing across multiple devices and browsers to ensure compatibility.

Conclusion

JavaScript’s role in SEO is often misunderstood, leading to misplaced blame for indexing and rendering issues. By using tools like Google Search Console, Rich Results Test, and Chrome DevTools, SEOs can systematically diagnose and resolve problems. Martin Splitt’s insights underscore the importance of thorough debugging and avoiding assumptions, ultimately saving time and improving site performance.

Understanding and addressing the root causes of indexing issues not only enhances SEO outcomes but also contributes to a more robust and efficient digital presence. With the right tools and knowledge, SEOs can confidently tackle challenges and ensure their websites are optimized for both users and search engines.

Also Read: Discover Google Saved: The Bookmarking Tool You Didn’t Know You Needed

Watch Martin Splitt’s presentation here:

---

FAQs